evaluating-skill-quality
Review a SKILL.md (and its references/) against a nine-dimension quality rubric, separating deterministic shape from probabilistic maturity, citing concrete evidence per dimension. Use when reviewing any SKILL.md -- this repository's own or one vendored from elsewhere -- before merging, vendoring, or shipping it, for a one-shot static quality verdict; see battle-testing-a-skill for adversarial hostile-input probing, and scorer-gated-skill-edits for a measured edit loop, instead.
Pinned to revision 1d6444696221, so it is the text this page describes rather than whatever the author pushed since.
Files
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/SKILL.md
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/metadata/gitapex.yaml
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/references/adversarial-self-audit.md
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/references/output-schema.json
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/references/rubric.md
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/references/runtime-compatibility.md
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/references/script-test-quality.md
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/references/skill-metadata.schema.json
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/references/state-management-quality.md
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/references/worked-example-explaining-the-work.md
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/references/worked-example-self-review.md
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/scripts/gitapex_check_skill_shape.py
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/scripts/gitapex_scan_execution_requirements_drift.py
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/scripts/test_gitapex_check_skill_shape.py
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/scripts/test_gitapex_contract_precondition_sync.py
- skills/evaluating-skill-quality/scripts/test_gitapex_scan_execution_requirements_drift.py
Every link opens the file at its source, pinned to the revision this page describes.